Unlikely Story by Ali Rosen (March 1, 2025) Many thanks to Net Galley, Brilliance Audio, and Ali Rosen for the gifted listening copy of this book, which landed on my NetGalley shelf at exactly the moment I needed it.
Nora is a relationship therapist who also writes a popular advice column – under a pseudonym. But she’s been keeping a secret of her own: she’s in love with J, the editor of her column, despite the fact that they’ve never met. Their entire connection exists in the margin notes of her drafts, with J in London and Nora in NYC, yet he’s become the person she feels most herself with.
At the same time, Nora’s dealing with a new headache in her real life – Eli, her infuriating new neighbor, whose apartment renovations are testing her patience. But the more they clash, the more she realizes there’s something intriguing beneath Eli’s gruff exterior. Before she knows it, she’s caught between two very different men – one she’s known only through words and one whose presence is impossible to ignore. How can she have such deep feelings for both?
This is such a feel-good romance, not just about romantic love but also about self-worth and found family. While Nora’s connections with J and Eli drive the plot, the heart of the story lies in the vibrant community within her apartment building. Her complicated relationship with her parents makes it even more moving to see her discover people who genuinely want to love and support her. Like Rosen’s wonderful 2024 release (Alternative Endings), this book beautifully explores love in all its forms—romantic, platonic, and self-love. Utterly charming and full of heart.
🎧 Audiobook Notes 🎧
Carly Robins delivers a fantastic solo narration, skillfully bringing a variety of NYC accents, ages, and British characters to life. At 9 hours and 27 minutes, it’s a completely lovely audio experience that enhances the warmth and humor of the story.
Book: 🌟🌟🌟🌟💫
Audiobook: 🌟🌟🌟🌟💫
Spice: 🌶️
Book Smart Kate 