Glass-half-empty Abby Cohen is feeling the pressure. Her small-town Vermont coffee shop is struggling, her overly cheerful customer Seth seems determined to brighten her mornings (whether she likes it or not), and as the only Jewish member of the town’s tourism board, she’s suddenly tasked with organizing a last-minute Hanukkah festival—despite her own complicated feelings about her faith and the town’s lack of understanding about Judaism.
When Seth offers to help her find vendors for the festival, he has one condition: Abby must join him in NYC as his fake girlfriend to get his mom off his back. As they spend the eight nights of Hanukkah together with his friends and family, Abby finds herself reevaluating not just her faith but her friendships, her small-town life, and, of course, Seth himself.
What makes this book so special is how it thoughtfully explores Abby’s journey of rediscovering her religion, allowing her to separate it from the complexities of her family. Seth’s parents are a true highlight, offering warmth and wisdom that help Abby see how a partner with a completely different outlook can challenge and support you in unexpected ways. The story also cleverly addresses the widespread assumption that Hanukkah is simply a “blue and white Christmas,” offering sharp critiques through humor and insight.
🎧 On the Audiobook: Narrated by Kelli Tager, the audiobook brings these characters to life beautifully. Seth’s parents, in particular, were standout voices that stole every scene they were in!
This sweet, reflective, and romantic Hanukkah story is the perfect read for the holiday season. If you’re looking for a romance that’s equal parts heartwarming and thought-provoking, grab this one!
Book: 🌟🌟🌟🌟
Audiobook: 🌟🌟🌟🌟
Spice: 🌶️
Book Smart Kate 