Book Smart Kate

Book: 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟 Spice: 🌶️🌶️

by Alexandra Kiley (March 4, 2025) – A huge thank you to @akileybooks, @htp_hive, @canarystreetpress, and @netgalley for the opportunity to read one of my most anticipated 2025 releases! Also, a special shoutout to @bibliolater.alligator and @books_w_bex for buddy reading this with me. Below is my honest review.

Seven years ago, Brooke was on the cusp of everything she dreamed of—about to graduate from college, a top contender for a prestigious writing fellowship, and madly in love with Jack. But everything came crashing down. Now, she’s rebuilt her life, but instead of writing her own stories, she’s found success as a ghostwriter, living in the shadows of others’ words. Her latest project is her most important yet—helping her mentor, Mhairi, chronicle her extraordinary life. But when their editor critiques the draft for lacking “life,” Brooke is tasked with taking readers on an immersive journey. To do that, she must retrace Mhairi’s steps on the Isle of Skye trail, a path Mhairi first explored decades ago. There’s one catch: her photographer on this journey will be none other than Jack, the man who broke her heart seven years ago. As Mhairi’s nephew, Jack has his own reasons for ensuring his aunt’s story is told with beauty and truth.

With so much history, pain, and unresolved feelings between them, Brooke and Jack are forced to confront their past while navigating the challenges of the rugged trail. As the days and obstacles pass, they slowly begin to open up, sharing their regrets and rediscovering the deep connection they once had.

This novel is a breathtakingly emotional second-chance romance, skillfully told through dual POV and dual timelines. We get to experience both their first meeting and the aftermath of their heartbreak, creating an electric contrast between the passion of their initial connection and the sorrow of their separation. Their bond is anchored not only in their past relationship but also in their mutual love for Mhairi, whose wisdom and life story deeply influence both of them. Mhairi’s insights, woven through both past and present, are pivotal to the plot, as is the stunning setting of the Isle of Skye. I found myself Googling each landmark, captivated by the beauty of the adventure Brooke and Jack were on.

Some books offer a great story but weak writing, while others have gorgeous prose but lack a strong plot. This book excels in both, blending a compelling plot with some of the most beautiful writing I’ve encountered this year. It’s a heart-wrenching, deeply emotional journey that I won’t soon forget.